Some of our favorite Hollywood starlets were caught wearing the same dresses lately…so the question is “Who’s IceCream tastes better?”

Kate Beckinsale vs. Kim Kardashian

We pick: Kate. Kim K’s makeup makes this dress look goth. Kate’s soft hair and makeup makes the look more glam.

Hayden Panettierre  vs. Taraji Henson

We pick: Taraji! She is working this dress..Hayden’s coat killed this look.

Katy Perry vs. Ashanti

We pick: Well..it’s a tie. But Ashanti could have done something better with her hair.

Carrie Underwood vs. Gabrielle Union

We pick: Gabrielle..but Carrie’s shoes are better.

What do you think?