IceCream Disaster: Pia Toscano eliminated from A.I.

America, what were you thinking?!!!

My FAVORITE contestant on American Idol, Pia Toscano was eliminated last night in one of the most shocking A.I. eliminations EVER!

Pia did her best rendition of Tina Turner’s “River Deep, Mountain High” Wednesday night; and apparently it wasn’t good enough for America’s votes.

Pia found herself in the bottom 3 along with my second favorite Jacob Lusk, and not so favorite Stefano Langone.

The question that many of us found ourselves asking was: Why were Pia and Jacob in the bottom 3 anyways? They are the BEST singers on the show! Many of us picked Pia, Jacob, and rocker James Durbin in the finale.

There’s no question that STEFANO should have went home last night. Honestly, I don’t understand why he is still even on the show! He’s boring, has no “star-power”, and will not be a huge commercial success.

Even Stefano was shocked that Pia was sent home and he got to stay on the show another week. The bewildered look on his face when Ryan Seacrest said he was safe, said exactly what we were all thinking: WTF?!

I also believe that the judges only “save” should have not been used on Casey Abrams. Casey is a good singer, but when he was spared from elimination; I feared that someone better like Pia or Jacob would be sent packing.

And that is exactly what happened.

America you got it wrong this doubt about it.

Free Shipping at



Author: BeccaSTAR

Share This Post On